[MD] Freedom

[Andre Broersen]

Arlo:
>?freedom is not possible without chance, probability, chaos,
> unexpected consequences, etc.

Craig:
Suppose if I pull lever A, a train is diverted to a harmless side track.

If I don't pull lever A, the train continues & runs over innocent bystanders.
I don't see how "chance, probability, chaos,?unexpected consequences,
etc." are necessary to make my action free.
If fact the opposite is true.? Unless I have a
reasonable?expectation?of?what my choices are , I can not make a
choice.

Andre:
Seems to me that both of you are talking about the same thing
(freedom) but different contexts:

Arlo: dynamic
Craig: static.

But I stand corrected

Cheers
Andre