[MD] French ingredient in the soup of sentiments

Arlo Bensinger ajb102 at psu.edu
Tue Apr 4 08:50:20 PDT 2006


[Platt]

If "individuals" are supreme over society, why do you care none for the 
"individuals" being killed in the name of preserving "American society", 
let's talk those who are nothing but "collateral" and not threats themselves?

And as always, your SOMist-minded "only two choices are "individuals 
removed from culture" and "society devoid of individuals"" is nonsensical. 
Pirsig's emergentist paradigm gives us a third way out, where collective 
activity of individuals on one level gives rise to the emegent, higher 
level structure above it.

Inorganic "individuals" collective activity gives rise to the biological 
level, where biological "individuals" collective activity gives rise to the 
social level, where social level "individuals" collective activity gives 
rise to the intellectual level. The collective activity of individuals on 
the intellectual activity (the law of gravity, calculus, thermodynamics, 
habeas corpus, etc.) may someday give rise to yet another emergent level.

Arlo




More information about the Moq_Discuss mailing list