[MD] Julian Baggini Interview with Pirsig
Ant McWatt
antmcwatt at hotmail.co.uk
Fri Jan 13 18:02:38 PST 2006
David,
What you said (pasted below) is very much how I felt about the Baggini
interview. In fact, I'll go as far to say that it reflected my experience
of the usual academic response to Pirsig, Zen etc.
For instance, do you think I chose Spinoza as part of my PhD on Pirsig's
work?
Anyway, moving away from yesterday's ideas, here's a glass to Albert
Hofmann's 100th birthday and a Dynamic high quality future:
"Father of LSD, now 100, and his 'problem child'"
By Craig S. Smith "The New York Times"
MONDAY, JANUARY 9, 2006
Switzerland - Albert Hofmann, the father of LSD, walked slowly across the
small corner office of his modernist home on a grassy Alpine hilltop here,
hoping to show a visitor the vista that sweeps before him on clear days.
But outside there was only a white blanket of fog hanging just beyond the
crest of the hill. He picked up a photograph of the view on his desk
instead, left there perhaps to convince visitors of what really lies beyond
the window.
Hofmann turns 100 on Wednesday, a milestone to be marked by a symposium in
nearby Basel on the chemical compound that he discovered and that famously
altered consciousnesses around the world. As the years accumulate and his
time left on the planet grows short, Hofmann's conversation turns ever more
insistently around one theme: man's oneness with nature and the dangers of
an increasing inattention to that fact.
"It's very, very dangerous to lose contact with living nature," he said.
"In the big cities, there are people who have never seen living nature, all
things are products of humans," he said. "The bigger the town, the less they
see and understand nature."
And, yes, LSD, which he calls his "problem child," could help reconnect
people to the universe.
Rounding a century, Hofmann is physically reduced but mentally clear. He is
prone to digressions, but his bright eyes flash with the recollection of a
mystical experience he had on a forest path more than 90 years ago in the
hills above Baden, Switzerland. The experience left him longing for a
similar glimpse of what he calls "a miraculous, powerful, unfathomable
reality," but it also left him deeply connected to nature and helped shape
his future.
He became particularly fascinated by the plant kingdom, by the mechanisms
through which plants turn sunlight into the building blocks for our own
bodies.
"Everything comes from the sun via the plant kingdom," he said.
He says that any natural scientist who is not a mystic is not a real natural
scientist.
Hofmann went on to study chemistry and took a job with Sandoz, a Swiss
pharmaceutical firm, because the company had started a program to identify
and synthesize the active compounds of medically important plants. He soon
began work on the poisonous ergot fungus that grows in grains of rye.
Midwives had used the deadly material for centuries to precipitate
childbirths, but chemists had never succeeded in isolating the chemical that
produced the pharmacological effect. Finally, chemists in the United States
identified the active component as lysergic acid, and Hofmann began
combining other molecules with the unstable chemical in search of
pharmacologically useful compounds.
Hofmann's work produced several important drugs, including a compound to
prevent hemorrhaging after childbirth. But it was the 25th compound that he
synthesized, lysergic acid diethylamide, that was to have the greatest
impact, although it yielded no significant pharmacological results.
When his other work on ergot was completed, he decided to go back to LSD-25,
hoping that improved pharmacological tests could detect the stimulating
effect on the body's circulatory system that he had expected from the
compound.
It was as he was synthesizing the drug on a Friday afternoon in April 1943,
he recalled, that he first experienced the altered state of consciousness
for which it became famous. He rode his bicycle home, lay down and spent
hours mesmerized by hallucinations.
"Immediately, I recognized it as the same experience I had had as a child,"
he said.
When he returned to his lab the next Monday, he tried to identify the source
of his strange experience, believing first that it had come from the fumes
of a chloroform-like solvent he had been using. Inhaling the fumes produced
no effect, though, and he realized he must have somehow ingested a trace of
LSD.
He first experimented with the drug, taking a dose so small that even the
most active toxin known at that time would have little or no effect. The
result was a powerful LSD experience, during which he again rode his bicycle
home, this time accompanied by an assistant.
He later participated in clinical tests in a Sandoz laboratory, but found
the experience frightening and realized that the drug should be used only
under carefully controlled circumstances.
Later, he wrote to the German novelist Ernst Jünger, who had experimented
with mescaline, and proposed that the two take the new compound together. In
1951, together with a medical doctor, the two men each took 0.05 milligrams
of pure LSD at Hofmann's home, accompanied by a vase of roses, music by
Mozart and a stick of Japanese incense.
"That was the first planned psychedelic test," Hofmann said.
He took the drug dozens of times after that, he said, and once experienced a
bad trip, what he calls a "horror trip," when he was tired and Jünger gave
him amphetamines first to freshen him up.
He calls LSD "medicine for the soul" and is frustrated by the worldwide
prohibition that has pushed it underground. "It was used very successfully
for 10 years in psychoanalysis," he said.
But the drug was hijacked by the youth movement of the 1960s and then
unfairly demonized by the establishment that the movement opposed, Hofmann
said. He conceded that LSD could be dangerous and called its indiscriminate
distribution by Timothy Leary and others "a crime."
"You should only give it to people with a certain stability who can survive
a bad trip," he said. "It should be a controlled substance with the same
status as morphine."
Hofmann is a philosopher but no high priest. He did not quit his job after
his LSD experiences but worked to retirement and lives now with his wife in
the house they built 38 years ago. He raised four children and watched one
son struggle with alcoholism before dying at the age of 53. He has eight
grandchildren and six great-grandchildren.
As far as he knows, no one in his family other than his wife has tried LSD.
When asked if the drug had deepened his understanding of death, he appeared
mildly startled and said no.
"I go back to where I came from, to where I was before I was born, that's
all," he said.
Basel on the chemical compound that he discovered and that famously altered
consciousnesses around the world. As the years accumulate and his time left
on the planet grows short, Hofmann's conversation turns ever more
insistently around one theme: man's oneness with nature and the dangers of
an increasing inattention to that fact.
"It's very, very dangerous to lose contact with living nature," he said.
"In the big cities, there are people who have never seen living nature, all
things are products of humans," he said. "The bigger the town, the less they
see and understand nature."
And, yes, LSD, which he calls his "problem child," could help reconnect
people to the universe.
Rounding a century, Hofmann is physically reduced but mentally clear. He is
prone to digressions, but his bright eyes flash with the recollection of a
mystical experience he had on a forest path more than 90 years ago in the
hills above Baden, Switzerland. The experience left him longing for a
similar glimpse of what he calls "a miraculous, powerful, unfathomable
reality," but it also left him deeply connected to nature and helped shape
his future...
He says that any natural scientist who is not a mystic is not a real natural
scientist.
Hofmann went on to study chemistry and took a job with Sandoz, a Swiss
pharmaceutical firm, because the company had started a program to identify
and synthesize the active compounds of medically important plants. He soon
began work on the poisonous ergot fungus that grows in grains of rye.
Midwives had used the deadly material for centuries to precipitate
childbirths, but chemists had never succeeded in isolating the chemical that
produced the pharmacological effect. Finally, chemists in the United States
identified the active component as lysergic acid, and Hofmann began
combining other molecules with the unstable chemical in search of
pharmacologically useful compounds.
Hofmann's work produced several important drugs, including a compound to
prevent hemorrhaging after childbirth. But it was the 25th compound that he
synthesized, lysergic acid diethylamide, that was to have the greatest
impact, although it yielded no significant pharmacological results.
When his other work on ergot was completed, he decided to go back to LSD-25,
hoping that improved pharmacological tests could detect the stimulating
effect on the body's circulatory system that he had expected from the
compound.
It was as he was synthesizing the drug on a Friday afternoon in April 1943,
he recalled, that he first experienced the altered state of consciousness
for which it became famous. He rode his bicycle home, lay down and spent
hours mesmerized by hallucinations.
"Immediately, I recognized it as the same experience I had had as a child,"
he said.
When he returned to his lab the next Monday, he tried to identify the source
of his strange experience, believing first that it had come from the fumes
of a chloroform-like solvent he had been using. Inhaling the fumes produced
no effect, though, and he realized he must have somehow ingested a trace of
LSD.
He first experimented with the drug, taking a dose so small that even the
most active toxin known at that time would have little or no effect. The
result was a powerful LSD experience, during which he again rode his bicycle
home, this time accompanied by an assistant.
He later participated in clinical tests in a Sandoz laboratory, but found
the experience frightening and realized that the drug should be used only
under carefully controlled circumstances.
Later, he wrote to the German novelist Ernst Jünger, who had experimented
with mescaline, and proposed that the two take the new compound together. In
1951, together with a medical doctor, the two men each took 0.05 milligrams
of pure LSD at Hofmann's home, accompanied by a vase of roses, music by
Mozart and a stick of Japanese incense.
"That was the first planned psychedelic test," Hofmann said.
He took the drug dozens of times after that, he said, and once experienced a
bad trip, what he calls a "horror trip," when he was tired and Jünger gave
him amphetamines first to freshen him up.
He calls LSD "medicine for the soul" and is frustrated by the worldwide
prohibition that has pushed it underground. "It was used very successfully
for 10 years in psychoanalysis. You should only give it to people with a
certain stability who can survive a bad trip," he said. "It should be a
controlled substance with the same status as morphine."
Hofmann is a philosopher but no high priest. He did not quit his job after
his LSD experiences but worked to retirement and lives now with his wife in
the house they built 38 years ago. He raised four children and watched one
son struggle with alcoholism before dying at the age of 53. He has eight
grandchildren and six great-grandchildren.
As far as he knows, no one in his family other than his wife has tried LSD.
When asked if the drug had deepened his understanding of death, he appeared
mildly startled and said no.
"I go back to where I came from, to where I was before I was born, that's
all," he said.
http://www.iht.com/articles/2006/01/06/news/profile.php
Ignore Hofmann (and Pirsig) at your peril!
Chin, chin,
Anthony.
>From: "David M" <davidint at blueyonder.co.uk>
>Reply-To: moq_discuss at moqtalk.org
>To: <moq_discuss at moqtalk.org>
>Subject: Re: [MD] Julian Baggini Interview with Pirsig
>Date: Fri, 13 Jan 2006 23:17:25 -0000
>
>Hi
>
>Does look like a missed opportunity.
>Did JB even read the books?
>As for using Spinoza for comparison,
>hard to think of a less relevant choice,
>not even well known to the general reader
>of a phil mag. A discussion about empiricism,
>experience and William James may have got
>somewhere. To my mind there is much to say
>about Pirsig and the approach of Heidegger
>and phenomenology (which tries to describe
>experience without assuming SOM). Also
>Roy Bhaskar (interviewed by TPM awhile
>ago) also has connections to Pirsig regarding
>levels, causality and ontological pluralism.
>Even Rorty is anti-essentialist like Pirsig and
>this is the very reason Pirsig could not describe
>what substance underpinned MOQ, that's the whole
>point of it being a very funny sort of metaphysics with
>DQ as a part of it, a source of creativity, also can be
>called Nothing, and SQ only being patterns identified
>(creatively, eg S/O is a created conception) in experience
>and with no underlyting substance (only Nothing)!
>JB was entirely asking the wrong
>questions, shame Bob could not find a better way to
>get him onto relevant ones. In a way Bob should have
>made more of a splash in Continental Phil as Chris
>Norris suuggested in his Deconstruction book,
>but he is known mainly in Ang-US circles and Ang-US
>philosophy is mainly bothered about language phil
>and that can be discussed in MOQ terms but has not
>been discussed much by Bob or us. Of course pragmatism
>and Qualia could be entry points. Spinoza! That looks like
>an ambush or a very unfortunate accident, like being run over!
>
>DM
>
>
_________________________________________________________________
Be the first to hear what's new at MSN - sign up to our free newsletters!
http://www.msn.co.uk/newsletters
More information about the Moq_Discuss
mailing list