[MD] NHS? No thanks
Arlo Bensinger
ajb102 at psu.edu
Mon Apr 16 05:36:05 PDT 2007
[Platt]
AHHHH yourself. You ignored the fact that our police and military
preserve, not destroy, liberty. Critical thinking strikes again.
[Arlo]
Not at all, Platt. You said, and I quote, "You do not see that the
power to tax is the power to destroy." I don't see any provisions in
that statement. Indeed, by saying now that "our police and military
preserve, not destroy, liberty", you are in fact saying the opposite,
namely that "the power to tax is the power to preserve liberty". I
agree, Platt, and now you've just proved my point. Thanks.
Or let's take another one of your statements. "Taxation, an assault
on man's pocketbook, is an assault on a man's liberty." Obviously
not, since taxation as you point out above funds a program that
preserves, not destroys, liberty. So again, you proven my point,
taxation supports social infrastructure that enables, not destroys, liberty.
Funny how you mock critical thinking, but it makes sense seeing as
all you offer instead is rhetorical distortion and inconsistent
little propagandistic one-liners.
[Platt]
Government brings wonderful things? Right, like concentration camps.
[Arlo]
Public libraries, free roads and waterways, public lands, museums,
municipal services, social safety net, consumer protection,
environmental protection, land management, yes, I'd say government
brings us wonderful things.
[Platt]
I don't see those professors being fired for defamation like Imus. Why not?
[Arlo]
Tenure, for good or bad, protects the liberty of the academy to speak
out against injustice without fear of reprisal. But again, this was
not the first time in American history an angry lynch mob with
torches and pitchforks went after someone. Why does it surprise you
now? It's the American way. Conservatives, liberals, blacks, whites,
makes no difference. You did the same thing, in many ways, with your
proclamation about the NHS, determining guilt before reading the
article or understanding the facts. And you called a challenge to do
so "preparing a thesis". But at any rate, I'm sure there will be many
more angry mobs in our future. Shock sells. We love to scapegoat and
blame "an enemy", whether its immigrants, blacks, the white man,
Jews, Arabs, commies, Nazis, whatever. Welcome to America.
More information about the moq_discuss
mailing list