[MD] What is SOM?
Krimel
Krimel at Krimel.com
Thu Dec 20 08:04:36 PST 2007
[Bo]
There are surely more S/O derivatives, Mind/body, mental/
corporeal, abstract/concrete and the said symbol/what's
symbolized are obvious.
[Krimel]
I would say the Greek contribution was more along the abstract/concrete
continuum. They appreciated the contribution of mathematical idealization so
much that it led them to devalue the actual messy world of the concrete.
[Bo]
One more subtle is nurture/nature but as
we know, these two never agrees on who determines mankind, so
it's typical S/O.
[Krimel]
Nature sets the range of possibility. Nurture provides that stage.
[Bo]
"Soul" was Greece's contribution to Judaism that
constituted Christianity so soul/body is another dichotomy.
[Krimel]
Greek influence on Judaism at least insofar as it is expressed in the Jewish
cannon is non-existence. The Jewish scriptures were all written prior to
Alexander's spreading of Hellenism. The Jews heard the idea of a 'soul'
from the Egyptians, Babylonians and Assyrians but they did not seem to make
much of it.
[Bo]
SOM has had an enormous influence on Western philosophy by
creating the problem (all western thinking are footnotes to Plato
they say) and has coloured all "solutions".
[Krimel]
That bit of self serving hyperbola comes from the Platonist Whitehead. Neat
guy and widely quoted but to be taken with a grain of salt.
More information about the Moq_Discuss
mailing list