[MD] Quality decline in U.S. politics
Arlo Bensinger
ajb102 at psu.edu
Mon Jul 16 08:56:25 PDT 2007
[Platt]
If not the voters, who do you think should decide?
[Arlo]
So, just so we are clear, you believe that states should be able to
decide whether or not to recognize interracial marriage. Is that correct?
[Arlo had asked]
The same argument was made when "interracial marriage" became an
issue. We were told that allowing "blacks and whites" to wed would
undermine social values, erode society away and lead to all sorts
of social ills. Why has that changed?
[Platt]
To many minds who see a general degeneration of society it hasn't.
[Arlo]
Are you saying there is validity to the argument that interracial
marriage contributes to the degeneration of society?
[Platt]
Says you. What's necessarily "violent" about drug abuse,
prostitution, pornography and lawlessness? And as usual, you
introduce a personal attack.
[Arlo]
In your litany of associations with gay marriage you include, and I
quote, "out-of-wedlock births, prostitution and
pornography, violence, drugs, profane language, discipline,
upholding the law, etc., etc., all of which undermine the bonds that
hold a society together". These are the things you wish to equate
with "gay marriage"
Also note the word "violence" in your statement.
As for the "personal attack", cry me a river. Its an atrocious
rhetoric association, sorry if that bothers you to have it pointed out.
[Platt]
I was answering Keith's argument. Your question is nonsensical.
[Arlo]
Just to be clear, you agree that whether or not "marriage" encourages
long-term relationships should not be a basis for its social
recognition? Yes or no.
More information about the Moq_Discuss
mailing list