[MD] Is morality Hard Wired?
Krimel
Krimel at Krimel.com
Wed May 30 14:21:06 PDT 2007
[Platt]
Human history, especially of the twentieth century, belies the notion that
hard-wired benevolence is difficult to overcome. It suggests instead that
we are hard-wired for aggression, especially against those who are strangers
and/or different than us. Co-operation is pretty much limited to one's own
in-group. Or, as Pirsig wrote, "Cooperation without coercion is a
devastating fiction."
[Krimel]
Let's take this really slowly one more time. Human history, all of it, is
irrelevant to this discussion.
History, by definition means during the period after people started writing
things down. That would be about 12,000 years ago, about the time that
agriculture developed and group population sizes began to exceed what we are
biologically equipped to deal with.
Human experience since the invention of history has been at odds with the
experience out of which we developed. But please note as I said a couple of
times there is a distinction between within and between group violence.
Being at odds with strangers is also a part of inherited morality. It is
particularly dangerous in historic times because there are so many more
strangers about.
More information about the Moq_Discuss
mailing list