[MD] Descartes in a MOQ light.
Arlo Bensinger
ajb102 at psu.edu
Mon Nov 5 12:14:28 PST 2007
[Ham]
As I understand the MoQ's interpretation of Intellect, it is not a
human attribute but some abstract level of Quality that is
apprehended by humans at an appropriate stage of their development.
[Arlo]
Not in any way. According to (my understanding of) the MOQ, the
"intellectual level" emerges from social activity. It was not sitting
there waiting to be apprehended, but an evolutionary/emergent level
of static patterns, which derive from- but are greater than- social
collective activity. Of course these levels, once emerged, enact
coercion on the levels from which they derive. Biological patterns
influence the behavior of their inorganic components. Social patterns
influence the behavior of their biological construents. And
intellectual patterns influence the behavior of their social-level
foundations. In this way, as any biological human is socialized, s/he
appropriates the customs and ideas of her/his culture, which exacts
great influence on the customs and ideas of this emerging "individual".
I'd say part of your misunderstanding is in the presentation that all
this is "isolated man and Eternal Essence". In this, of course, it
would be ridiculous to suppose that Intellect is floating around
waiting for isolated-man to apprehend it. Understanding and
recognizing the role of human collective and social activity
overcomes this dilemma. But that's an old can of worms, no point in rehashing.
More information about the Moq_Discuss
mailing list