[MD] differences between MoQ and SOM

Platt Holden plattholden at gmail.com
Wed Oct 22 09:48:11 PDT 2008


> "If 1) chemistry professors exercise choice, and 2) chemistry professors
> are 
> composed exclusively of atoms, then it follows that 3) atoms must exercise
> choice too." (Pirsig, "Lila", Chap. 12) 
> 
> Pirsig's position is that chemistry professors ARE NOT composed
> exclusively
> of atoms.  Atoms are not alive, don't have tenure & don't know
> chemistry.
> The MoQ levels address this issue.

2) is the claim of SOM science. You are correct. Pirsig uses the syllogism 
to show where SOM collapses.   

Platt



More information about the Moq_Discuss mailing list