[MD] The Quality of Freedom

[ARLO J BENSINGER JR]

[Ham]
In summary, I maintain that it is a moral travesty to dismiss or reject the
discriminative and rational faculties with which human beings are uniquely
endowed. 

[Arlo]
Prior to this, you deny the source of this "unique endowment" as either
biological (genetics) or social (enculturation). So I ask you, again, where
does this "unique endowment" come from? 

Let me rephrase. I assume that at some point, let's call it Point A, this
"unique endowment" did not exist within the "cosmos". At a latter point, let's
call it Point B, it does exist within the "cosmos". What changed between Points
A and B that accounts for the appearance of this "unique endowment"?