[MD] The Quality/MOQ dichotomy.

Krimel Krimel at Krimel.com
Sun Feb 1 10:24:27 PST 2009


dmb said:
In the MOQ there is no "out there". The idea of an independent external
reality is just that, an idea.

Krimel replied:
I would say this view of the MoQ is indistinguishable from solipsism.

dmb says:
Solipsism is a problem arises when one is thinking within those Cartesian
assumptions we call SOM. But the MOQ rejects those assumptions and instead
agrees that our ideas are culturally derived and so the problem of being
trapped in your own subjectivity doesn't come up. 

[Krimel]
Culturally derived? Cartesian assumptions? From whence does "culture" and
"assumption" come? If there is no "out there" how is your form of radical
idealism different from solipsism. Saying that you are rejecting solipsism
by rejecting Descartes is just rearranging the bumper stickers on your car. 

By the way Descartes "cogito" is not at all to be equated with Cartesian
dualism. 




More information about the Moq_Discuss mailing list