[MD] Christendom's place in the MOQ

[david buchanan]

"Cultures can be graded and judged morally according to their contribution to the evolution of life." (Lila, 24) It really bothers me when Platt quotes Pirsig to support his reactionary, talk-radio nonsense. This is just one of the most recent examples. He dished it up as a response to accusations of cultural chauvinism, as if moral judgments and chauvinism were the same thing, or rather as if we can't tell the difference. If we are to judge cultures according to the evolution of life, then we have to identify what does and does not contribute to that ongoing process. There are at least two crucial factors that will determine the soundness of any such judgement; an adequate understanding of the situation in question and an understanding of the MOQ's moral hierarchy. Basically, Platt has neither of these. He seems to get his news from Fox and constantly demonstrates confusion about what is social and what is intellectual and apparently this confusion has everything to do with his chauvinism. He simply puts all the stuff he likes into the intellectual category and the things he does not like are characterized as social or biological. Most often it is only HIS ranking of things, not Pirsig's. In my opinion, Platt is the least helpful MOQer of all time. He's incorrigible. I'm astonished that anyone could hang around here for so long without learning anything at all. And he doesn't seem to grade or morally judge other cultures so much as he denigrates them in ditto-head, parrot-like fashion. Can you, dear MOQer, tell the different between a cultural analysis based on an evolutionary moral principle and one based on low-brow patriotism? I can. It's one of the reasons I delete Platt's posts without even reading them. If nobody responded I would see even less of them, which would be fine with me.   
_________________________________________________________________
Windows Live™: Keep your life in sync. 
http://windowslive.com/explore?ocid=TXT_TAGLM_WL_t1_allup_explore_012009