[MD] Another parallel
craigerb at comcast.net
craigerb at comcast.net
Mon Jul 13 18:05:57 PDT 2009
[Craig, previously]
> But is it MORE MORAL for a bad idea to kill a good society than it is
> for a good society to kill a bad idea?
[dmb}
> the suggestion that it's OKAY for a society to kill ideas defies
> the MOQ's moral hierarchy.
Careless change from “MORE MORAL” to “OKAY”
[dmb] > the suggestion that it's okay for a society to kill ideas defies the
> MOQ's moral hierarchy. Qualifying the hypothetical society with
> "good" and qualifying the ideas as "bad" doesn't alter that
> principle.
David mb, I find many of your arguments interesting. But when you make an
assertion without support, it is very frequently wrong. I don’t think
you have a good grasp of the data.
[dmb]
> bad ideas are [not] going to be killed by social values.
And here’s the perfect example. Follow the news.
Cuba , Red China, the Taliban, etc. are notorious for killing good ideas,
often along with those who hold them.
.
[dmb]
> Craig's question strikes me as the verbal equivalent of a card trick.
”Flattery will get you nowhere.”
Craig
More information about the Moq_Discuss
mailing list