[MD] The New Socialism - Wired Magazine
craigerb at comcast.net
craigerb at comcast.net
Wed Jun 3 16:04:08 PDT 2009
[Craig, previously]
> In general my complaint is against the following kind of reasoning:
> Step 1) Take a concept like freedom (or meaning).
> Step 2) Define it in an EXTREME way.
> ...In contrast to this “strawman” mode of reasoning, consider
> concepts on a spectrum. At one end of the spectrum, markets can be
> highly regulated, with government owning the means of production,
> setting wages & prices, as in socialism proper. Or at the other
> end, government can just establish the structure of the market,
> without competing in it or dictating economic exchanges, as in free
> markets.
[Arlo]
> I wish you'd have the same complaints about how you do this to the
> concept of "socialism".
But I do define ‘socialism’ as on a spectrum (see above). [Arlo]
> Would it be an example of "socialism" for the state to regulate
> marriage as only between same-race couples?
I think we should confine the term ‘socialism’ to the economic realm,
as I did above. Your example, is one of ‘social engineering’.
[Arlo]
> Gee, Craig, forgive me
OK, but only if you say 3 Our Adam Smith’s, 2 Hail Rand’s & sin no more. Craig
More information about the Moq_Discuss
mailing list