[MD] Coerce me? How?

Arlo Bensinger ajb102 at psu.edu
Tue Jun 9 13:37:39 PDT 2009


[Ron]
generally speaking yes, but it's the particular ideas that are 
not self evident. All people have ideas, but not every idea is held 
by all people.

[Arlo]
Exactly. And it is the enactment of civil governance that gives one 
set of ideas legitimacy over another. Indeed, we enact government to 
say "we believe this idea is best" and to provide the authority to 
back up its instantiation. "Private property" is one such idea, that 
is not "self-evident", but comes from the social and historical 
underpinnings to modern man's reasoning. And we enacted a government 
that legitimizes "property rights" and provides an authority to back them up.

Without this, you'd just have two guys standing on a hill.

"This hill is mine."
"No, this hill doesn't 'belong' to any one, it is free land for all 
people to enjoy."

Who is "right"? Whoever can convince more people. Whoever has the 
authority of civil governance on their side to legitimize their claim.

"Self-evident" is a buzzword, and it usually means, "it's the way I 
personally think" with an appeal to a "higher power" to justify that 
your beliefs are right and everyone else's are wrong.








More information about the Moq_Discuss mailing list