[MD] Subjectivity in the MOQ

[craigerb at comcast.net]

[Ham] 
> If Goodness were absolute (or fixed) there would be no need for 
> morality, since it would be impossible to choose the alternative. 
[Ham, reconstructed] 
1) Morality is needed only if choice is possible. 
2) Choice is possible only if there is more than one alternative. 
3) Morality is needed. 
4) :. There is more than one alternative. 
5) If only one choice is good, there is only one alternative. 
6) :. Not only one choice is good. 
7) If Goodness were absolute, only one choice would be good. 
8) :. Goodness is not absolute. 


Unfortunately, for this argument, 5) is not true. 
Craig