[MD] William James a wrong track..

[skutvik at online.no]

13 March Andre Broersen wrote:

Mati before:
> > Imagining situation is part of the reflective understanding of what
> > emotions are.  I would so very humbly suggest that perhaps the idea of
> > emotion as strictly social is also a fallout of SOM. Understanding
> > emotions is I would agree a social phenomenon, but experiencing them is
> > originally a biological one.

> Hi Mati, you confirm what I suggested (and many others) a few posts
> ago. No need to be humble about it. What I find so sad about Bodvar's
> position is That he has so much to offer the MoQ but fails to do so
> because he is stuck in this SOL of his...and fanatic about his
> criticism of Pirsig in the process.

Spare me your exasperation over my "having so much to offer" 
nonsense. The day you will tell me what your alleged understanding  
"has to offer" I will listen, but as far none of you have offered 
anything, for instance for Craig to present Strawson with. While the 
only argument that will shut him up you oppose vehemently.  

Bodvar