[MD] Morality and Prudence
Matt Kundert
pirsigaffliction at hotmail.com
Thu Aug 25 15:58:57 PDT 2011
Hey Dan,
Yeah, it is interesting. I still think that both of your readings of Dexter
and Walt are very wrong, but I think it punches up just how much
interpolation must be done by the viewer to make sense of the story.
We see roughly the same evidence, but draw different conclusions,
conclusions that I think might be indeterminate to the evidence. For
example, I think an "inborn sense of morality" is antithetical to the
spirit of the show (and Pirsig's philosophy for that matter), but it's a
sense of the whole, not a little fact lying around that gives me that
sense. And vice versa on your side of it. And for Walt, I don't think
there's anything psychopathic about inadequacy or anger, nor do I
think he was a "bad guy" waiting to happen. I think the
extraordinary pressures of the situation, combined with the mounting
consequences and demands of each successive choice, creates his
course of evolution. But, there's still no evidential silver bullet.
Matt
More information about the Moq_Discuss
mailing list