[MD] Taking words Seriously
X Acto
xacto at rocketmail.com
Mon Oct 10 15:49:37 PDT 2011
Matt
p.s.
To anyone who is curious about what I think about Steve and Dave's
recent back-and-forth since I disappeared in the conversation, I tend
to agree with Steve's approach. I get more and more confused
about what Dave thinks the further it goes on, which I know Dave
thinks is disingenuous of me, but I just can't wrap my head around
some of the claims he thinks I'm making. Dave moves just too fast
for me through what he thinks I think, that there's no time, nor real
purpose for someone who has their mind made up, to try and go
back over them all. Dave's right that it is my reading of Rorty that
likely makes me so disagreeable to him, but I've apparently climbed
into a box that Dave sees no reason for ever letting me out of in his
own mind.
Ron:
Although that may be the case, it seems Daves fight is over different reasons.
I think Steve and yourself have a particularly fine line of discussion going concerning
Philosophy. However I feel Steve and Dave are talking past eachother and I think,
to my reading, Steve knows what Dave is on about but is teasing him out semantically.
just to fuk with him.
The problem that you and Dave share is well beyond anything I could even suggest.
Matt, you often take a rather complex read to uncover the subleties of your meaning
whereas Dave is more direct. If anything I could add, this would be the primary distiction
in your styles of discussion.
thnx
..
More information about the Moq_Discuss
mailing list