[MD] logically incoherent

[MarshaV]

On Sep 6, 2011, at 4:51 PM, Ham Priday wrote:

> 
> NOTHING can exist -- not Evolution or its "levels", not the material 
> universe, not Quality or the emotions, not Intellect or Experience, not even 
> the conscious Self -- in the absence of a Primary Source.  Again, Marsha, 
> I cite as my logic for this premise the 'ex nihilo nihil fit' proposition of classical 
> philosophy, the empirical precept of  'first cause', and the metaphysical 
> principle that Heidegger formulated in the question "Why are there beings 
> rather than nothing?"
> 


Hello Ham,

Can you provide proofs for your premises?   

Citing "classical philosophy" is an argument  from authority.  Is there a 
proof for the premise, 'ex nihilo nihil fit'?  Or is it true because the Ancient 
Greeks thought so? 

Please explain your "empirical precept for 'first cause'"? 

With all respect to Sir Doktor Professor Heidegger, where is your proof for 
the metaphysical adaptation of Heidegger's question?  


Marsha  
 
 
 

 
___