[MD] Re: logically incoherent

[MarshaV]

Andre,  

Your answer to Mr. Harris must be "Because I, Andre Broersen, say so."    But it's okay, you just keep getting your MD attention from writing posts to me.  I don't mind.  But it might be nice, for a change,  if you tried to submit a post with an interesting topic.  That would be cool.  
 
 
Marsha




On Sep 9, 2011, at 10:51 AM, MarshaV wrote:

> 
> On Jul 17, 2011, at 4:46 PM, MarshaV wrote:  
> 
> Andre, 
> 
> Let's say Sam Harris has read your 'An Open Letter by Andre Broersen to Sam Harris', he might ask:  You have categorized 'science' as an intellectual static pattern of value, but not explained what that means. 'Science' is a name, a designator, a label; what makes 'science' an intellectual pattern?  How do I differentiate an intellectual pattern from a social pattern?  How do I differentiate 'science' as an intellectual pattern from a social pattern?  
> 
> Do you tell him that 'science' is an intellectual pattern because you, Andre, say so?  Or do tell him 'science' is an intellectual pattern because Mr. Pirsig says so?  Or do you tell him 'science' is an intellectual pattern because the cultural glasses say so?  Or what? 
> 
> 
> Marsha 
> .  


 
___