[MD] Consciousness a la Platt

[Heather Perella]

Platt:
> Please jog my memory. When did I write "evolve,"

SA:  Didn't you say "consciousness changes" and you state "oops" is the answer?  I don't know if you used these words, exactly or not, but this is what the discussion was about.

Platt:
> "need for an origin" and
> "intention."

SA:  Discussion was about?

Platt: 
> Do you believe that anyone here is duty bound to answer
> questions when he 
> or she is described by the questioner as being a moron and
> a liar?

SA:  Platt, this is getting old, don't you think?  This whole discussion?  I'm trying to focus on the questions he asked.  He did answer your questions.

SA previously: 
> >      From my perspective, it's mainly been Ham,
> with his "consciousness
> > evolves" comment and then his blatant disregard
> to comment upon this quote
> > of his.  He probably doesn't even know what his
> own words mean.  It's his
> > track record.  His 'mo'.

Platt: 
> Without offering any evidence, you charge is ad hominem. 
> I'm surprised, 
> SA. It's not like you to be like Arlo. 

SA:  As I said to Ian in the Disagreement [MD], it depends on what you mean by ad hominem, for I don't see anything ad hominem about what I said, not at all.  Enlighten me.


SA