[MD] Ah-ha Qua Ah-ha
Matt Kundert
pirsigaffliction at hotmail.com
Wed Nov 24 10:20:09 PST 2010
Hi Mark,
Matt said:
To _abstract_ is to make _independent_. It is, in a word, _to isolate_.
Mark said:
Personally I see it much easier to view intellectualizing as creating. I
believe the Western world has the notion that something is being
uncovered through the process. This is most common in the
intellectualizing involved in science.
Matt:
Yeah, that puts the point as I would want to, but the relationship
between abstraction and creation is still too distant to be quickly or
easily understood. It's something I've been thinking about a lot lately.
When you isolate property A from object X, you are actually creating a
new object (i.e., A), which has its own context and qualities and
whatnot. Western philosophy has been working itself in this direction
(you can see it in Wittgenstein when he says in the Philosophical
Investigations that philosophical problems are created by the
transportation of perfectly serviceable concepts into different contexts),
but it is still held back, as you point out, by the notion that "truth is an
uncovering" (which is one way to translate the Greek word for truth,
"aletheia") that is still encouraged by most of the rhetoric surrounding
science.
Matt
More information about the Moq_Discuss
mailing list